On this episode of Coaches Interrupted, I sat down with the guys to argue about a hot take one of us posted on Instagram: do you really need to keep chest-to-bar pull-ups in your training during the offseason? From there we played a few rounds of underrated or overrated, covering conjugate training for CrossFit, inversions for the general population, and the three movements we’d keep if we could only train three things for the rest of our lives.
The original take was built for engagement. The conversation that followed is a much better answer for athletes and coaches actually writing an offseason.
The short version: Chest-to-bar pull-ups don’t need high volume year-round, but they shouldn’t disappear either. Keep a small, regular dose in the offseason (think a weekly touch), build the supporting strength and tissue tolerance with other pulling and shoulder work, and ramp volume up as competition gets closer. Athletes with real technical gaps need more practice, not less.
Should chest-to-bar pull-ups be in your offseason training?
Yes, but at a low dose. The coaches landed on keeping them in year-round, with very different volume depending on the time of year and the athlete.
The original argument was that you don’t need a ton of chest-to-bar when you’re far away from competition, because other movements train most of what it needs:
- Toes-to-bar and bar muscle-ups for straight-arm pulling and kipping mechanics.
- Ring muscle-ups for similar elbow flexion and rear-delt pulling.
- Rows and posterior cuff strengthening to build tissue that can handle the volume later.
The pushback was that “far from competition” and “never” aren’t the same thing. When a movement disappears completely, it takes a long time to rebuild the ability to recover from it. Eight weeks out isn’t enough runway to get someone sharp if they’ve ignored it all year.
Why is the chest-to-bar pull-up a risky movement to train in high volume?
Because the volume it takes to move the needle for an advanced athlete puts the shoulder in a compromised position a lot of times.
For a semifinals-level athlete to get a challenging training effect from chest-to-bar, the rep counts get high, and so do the number of reps where they fall through at the bottom. Doing that year-round can be costly for shoulder health. The argument for less volume is to build the tissue in other, less taxing ways, then give a technically sound athlete an appropriate runway closer to competition.
Everyone agreed it’s a problematic movement. It’s also part of the sport, so the answer isn’t removing it. It’s being tactful about how it’s dosed.
What does a minimum effective dose look like?
Something like a weekly touch in the offseason, scaled up as competition approaches.
- A volume target per movement. One of the coaches programs off a volume checklist, setting a “functional volume” for in-season and out of season. Far from competition, that can be around 40 reps in a week.
- A light touch inside other training. For one advanced athlete, chest-to-bar shows up about once every other week as part of a piece, just so the movement isn’t novel (and doesn’t cause a ton of soreness) when volume comes back.
- Supporting work. Things like barbell drop catches and accessory pulling build tolerance alongside the movement itself.
It’s similar to running. Lots of people get hurt running, but the answer isn’t to only run in the six weeks before a competition. You do quality work and supportive training in the offseason so your joints get the longest possible runway to adapt.
What if you’re bad at chest-to-bar pull-ups?
Then you need to practice them, and the offseason is a good time to do it.
If an athlete has technical issues with butterfly chest-to-bar, they need practice. How much depends on how strong and resilient their shoulder tissue is. And practice doesn’t just mean doing a bunch of reps in workouts:
- Pull the movement apart and train the pieces.
- Build strict pulling strength.
- Practice in untimed settings so efficiency and movement economy improve before fatigue gets involved.
Someone already built for gymnastics can get away with a touch. Someone who isn’t needs to move the needle, and that takes time.
What makes a movement a “poor training tool”?
That’s where the take got a little myopic. If “poor training tool” means a movement can be done badly, has poor transfer for some people, or carries more risk, then lots of movements fall into that bucket. For an uncoordinated athlete, you could say the same thing about a burpee box jump-over or a snatch.
The two movements that stand out for high risk-to-reward in high volumes are the butterfly chest-to-bar pull-up and the kipping handstand push-up. Rope climbs, bar muscle-ups, ring muscle-ups and strict handstand push-ups can usually be driven harder as long as there’s no pre-existing injury.
The two risky movements also differ from each other. Kipping handstand push-ups never get very metabolically demanding, and the better you get, the easier they feel, so you end up mostly loading your cervical spine. Chest-to-bar is fast and uses a big range of motion, so it’s metabolically demanding and you can push through fatigue a bit more than you can with pressing muscles that fail suddenly.
Is it a coach’s job to protect athlete health or to get them ready to compete?
Both, and keeping chest-to-bar in year-round is how you do both.
One commenter on the original post pushed back that CrossFit is a fitness competition, not a health competition. That’s fair: athletes don’t make the rules. But you have to be healthy enough to participate, and the coach guards that. As one of the guys put it, “My job is to get them there and have them compete as well as they can at the sport.” Keeping the movement in, dosed carefully, is what keeps athletes resilient to it.
Is conjugate training underrated for CrossFit?
The coaches called it underrated. It’s not that they run pure conjugate, but several of its principles fit CrossFit well.
- Rotating max effort work keeps volume predictable. The volume of a max effort session doesn’t grow week to week, so it’s easier to fit the rest of the training around it than a linear squat cycle that keeps getting bigger.
- Dynamic effort work brings something different. Speed and power work has been an untapped resource in CrossFit programming outside of Olympic weightlifting.
- Variety matches the test. You don’t know what the next competition’s lifting format will be, so regular heavy touches across different variations help.
- More frequent wins. Rotating variations gives athletes more chances to hit PRs.
The caveat is fatigue. Central nervous system fatigue has to be managed, and the mixed-modal work has to be dosed so it doesn’t interfere with the lifting. A newer athlete may just need more volume. An intermediate athlete who’s progressing fast can benefit from building to heavy sets because their percentages go stale quickly. Very strong athletes need more care, because they can dig deep enough to create too much fatigue.
Are inversions overrated for the general population?
This one split the room.
- The case for “underrated”: being able to get upside down and support yourself without being afraid is a good sign of shoulder health and upper-body supportive strength. You don’t need to do 100 reps, but it shouldn’t be the most horrifying thing in the world.
- The case for “overrated”: squatting, hinging, pressing, bracing your core and hanging from something add a lot of independence across your whole life. Going upside down on your hands doesn’t carry the same weight for a normal person’s daily life.
Everyone agreed on where it depends: CrossFit as a community probably overvalues inversions a little, and the broader strength and conditioning world probably places almost no value on them. For gym members, it’s worth asking whether being inverted is actually a goal, and if not, building the same supportive strength without being fully upside down.
What three movements would you keep for life?
If you could only keep three movements to give yourself the best chance at independence later in life, the answers were:
- Running, so you can move and get away from something.
- Sandbag carries (like a bear hug carry), because picking up awkward objects and carrying them is real-world strength.
- Burpees, because if you get knocked down, you can get back up.
A dead hang and swimming also came up as strong contenders.
Follow the coaches
Spencer: @spencercoaches
Tyson: @tysonmaherr
Ben: @ben.wise
Listen to The Fitness Movement on Apple Podcasts and Spotify.
Want programming built around you?
ZOAR Fitness coaches write individualized programming for competitive CrossFit athletes, including how much gymnastics volume you need and when.

